International child abduction and referral to the family court judge

Laurent Latapie Avocat droit international,ational Hong Kong
Laurent Latapie Avocat droit international,ational Hong Kong

A French woman, leaving Sweden in a hurry for France with her Swedish father’s child, can she seize the family court judge to “validate” and legitimize her installation in France? How to apply the Hague Convention of October 25, 1980 addressing the legal regime of international child abduction?

 

 

 

It is worth considering a judgment rendered by the Court of Cassation in September 2019 which addresses the issue of the application of the HAGUE Convention of October 25, 1980 on the civil aspects of international child abduction.

 

In this case, child E was born in Sweden to a Swedish father who had custody of him and a French mother.

 

The mother having, on January 17, 2017, left Sweden for France with the child, the father on February 5, 2017, applied to the Swedish authorities to obtain the return of the child to Sweden in application of the HAGUE Convention of 25 October 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.

 

By request of February 6, 2017, Ms. X asked the Family Affairs Judge to set the terms and conditions for the exercise of parental authority over the common child. However, the Public Prosecutor assigned him to order the immediate return of the child to the father’s home in Sweden. By reversal of February 27, 2018, the Court of Appeal allowed this request and ruling on the request filed by Mrs X before the Family Affairs Judge.

 

The Court of Appeal considered that the French judge was incompetent to decide this issue.

 

This judgment is interesting because it recalls the scope and the force of the HAGUE Convention allowing one of the parents victim of the abduction of a child to hope for a quick return of the latter.

 

The Public Prosecutor’s Office of the countries having ratified this convention is required to do all due diligence without delay.

 

The idea that the mother has referred the matter to the Family Affairs Judge is also a relevant and effective approach allowing her to legitimize the presence of the child on French territory.

 

Unfortunately in this case the procedure was vitiated by the fact that the mother created problems of address deceiving the Public Prosecutor’s Office which led to a severe application of the HAGUE Convention.

 

The Court of Cassation recalls that the absence or the inaccuracy of the mention relating to the residence of the applicant in cassation required by article 975 of the Code of Civil Procedure constitutes a formal irregularity likely to entail the nullity of the declaration of appeal. if it is justified that this irregularity causes a grievance to the defendant.

 

This decision offers a good example of recent application in France of the HAGUE Convention and it offers a reflection on the validity of the referral to the Family Affairs Judge in France to quickly determine and characterize the right of the parent residing in France.

 

 

Article written by Maître Laurent LATAPIE,

Lawyer, Doctor of Law,

www.laurent-latapie-avocat.fr

 

 

Divorce franco-algérien et fixation du premier domicile matrimonial

Laurent Latapie avocat droit de l'entreprise en difficulté 2020

Deux époux algériens se marient à Oran en 1982 pour s’installer en 1995 en France, obtenir la nationalité française et ne jamais retourner en Algérie. En cas de divorce et de liquidation du patrimoine commun, faut-il appliquer le droit français et son régime communautaire, ou le droit algérien et son régime séparatiste ? Faut-il retenir le critère du premier domicile matrimonial en Algérie ou prendre en considération les circonstances postérieures et leurs investissements immobiliers en France ?

Continue reading

Divorce franco-indonésien : mode de fonctionnement et collaboration

Laurent Latapie avocat banque

Dans quelles conditions une procédure de divorce fonctionne en Indonésie ? qu’en est-il pour un divorce entre un ressortissant français et un ressortissant indonésien ? Comment organiser et préparer un divorce franco-indonésien ? Nouvelle collaboration entre le cabinet de Maître Laurent Latapie, Avocat français, et le cabinet de Maitre Natalia Petracia Sahetapy, avocate à Jakarta, Indonésie.

Continue reading

Franco-Indonesian divorce: mode of operation and collaboration

Laurent Latapie Avocat immobilier et liquidation

What conditions does a divorce procedure work in Indonesia? what about a divorce between a french national and an indonesian national? How to organize and prepare a Franco-Indonesian divorce? New collaboration between the office of Maître Laurent Latapie, French lawyer, and the office of Maître Natalia Petracia Sahetapy, lawyer in Jakarta, Indonesia.

Continue reading

Perceraian Perancis-Indonesia: mode operasi dan kolaborasi

Laurent Latapie avocat banque

Dalam kondisi apa prosedur perceraian bekerja di Indonesia? bagaimana dengan perceraian antara warga negara Perancis dan warga negara Indonesia? Bagaimana cara mengatur dan mempersiapkan perceraian Prancis-Indonesia? Kolaborasi baru antara kantor Maître Laurent Latapie, pengacara Prancis, dan kantor Maître Natalia Petracia Sahetapy, pengacara di Jakarta, Indonesia.

Continue reading